The Banned Books of the 21st Century: Exploring Modern-Day Censorship in America

The Banned Books of the 21st Century: Exploring Modern-Day Censorship in America

The debate over banned books is far from a relic of the past. In the 21st century, book censorship in the United States has taken on new dimensions, often reflecting evolving social, cultural, and political tensions.

From school libraries to public debates, the fight over what literature is deemed "appropriate" reveals much about contemporary America’s values and challenges.

Let’s explore the stories behind some of the most notable banned books of the 2000s and what these controversies say about our society today.

Why Books Are Still Being Banned

At its core, book banning stems from a desire to protect specific values or shield readers—especially children—from potentially controversial topics.

However, in the modern era, the reasons for banning books have expanded, often reflecting societal debates around race, gender, sexuality, and political ideology.

While some argue that removing books with sensitive content creates a safer environment, others see it as a dangerous form of censorship that stifles critical thinking and the exploration of diverse perspectives.

Notable Banned Books of the 21st Century

1. The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas

  • Reason for the Ban: Profanity, references to drugs, and its depiction of police brutality.
  • Background: Angie Thomas’s bestselling novel explores systemic racism through the eyes of a teenage girl. It has been frequently challenged for its explicit language and depiction of controversial topics like police violence and protests, which some critics argue are “anti-police.”
  • Why It Matters: This book is a critical conversation starter about race and justice, making it an essential read despite its challenges.

2. Gender Queer: A Memoir by Maia Kobabe

  • Reason for the Ban: Explicit illustrations and LGBTQ+ content.
  • Background: Maia Kobabe’s graphic memoir details their journey of self-discovery as a nonbinary person. It has faced bans for its depictions of sexual identity and gender exploration, particularly in school libraries.
  • Why It Matters: Gender Queer has become one of the most banned books of recent years, reflecting broader cultural debates about LGBTQ+ representation in literature.

3. Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher

  • Reason for the Ban: Themes of suicide, bullying, and mental health.
  • Background: This YA novel follows the story of a teenage girl who leaves behind cassette tapes explaining her decision to take her life. Critics argue that it glamorizes suicide, leading to its removal from schools and libraries.
  • Why It Matters: The book brings important issues to light, sparking necessary conversations about mental health and bullying.

4. All American Boys by Jason Reynolds and Brendan Kiely

  • Reason for the Ban: Racism, drug use, and violence.
  • Background: This dual-perspective novel tackles racial profiling and police brutality, centering on the experiences of two high school boys—one Black, one white. Challenges often cite its “controversial” exploration of race and law enforcement.
  • Why It Matters: All American Boys pushes readers to confront uncomfortable truths about privilege, racism, and justice.

5. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie

  • Reason for the Ban: Profanity, sexual references, and depiction of alcoholism.
  • Background: This semi-autobiographical novel follows a Native American teenager navigating life on and off the reservation. While celebrated for its humor and honesty, it has faced challenges for its candid depiction of poverty and substance abuse.
  • Why It Matters: Alexie’s book sheds light on the struggles of Indigenous youth in modern America, giving a voice to underrepresented communities.

6. Fun Home: A Family Tragicomic by Alison Bechdel

  • Reason for the Ban: LGBTQ+ themes and graphic content.
  • Background: Bechdel’s acclaimed graphic memoir explores her relationship with her father and her journey of coming out as a lesbian. It has been criticized for its explicit imagery and LGBTQ+ content.
  • Why It Matters: Fun Home highlights the power of graphic storytelling in exploring identity and family dynamics.

7. Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi

  • Reason for the Ban: Graphic depictions of violence and criticism of authoritarian regimes.
  • Background: This memoir depicts the author’s childhood in Iran during and after the Islamic Revolution. Despite its literary acclaim, some schools have removed it for its portrayal of violence and political themes.
  • Why It Matters: Persepolis offers a window into a culture and history that is often misunderstood or oversimplified in Western narratives.

The Rise of Challenges in School Libraries

The American Library Association (ALA) has reported a sharp increase in book challenges over the past decade, with 2022 seeing the highest number of attempted bans in recent history.

A significant portion of these challenges targets books that address racial inequality, LGBTQ+ themes, or mental health. 

This surge often correlates with larger cultural and political movements, as book bans have increasingly become a flashpoint in debates over parental rights, education, and free speech.

The Impact of Banned Books

While banning a book may limit its immediate availability, it often amplifies interest in the title, making it a bestseller or sparking widespread public discourse.

Authors like Angie Thomas and Maia Kobabe have spoken out about how challenges to their books highlight the very issues they sought to address—racism, censorship, and representation.

Why Reading Banned Books Matters

Reading banned books isn’t just an act of rebellion; it’s an affirmation of intellectual freedom. These books challenge readers to think critically, engage with diverse viewpoints, and confront complex issues.

By reading banned books, we uphold the values of free expression and broaden our understanding of the world.

How to Support Banned Books and Intellectual Freedom

  1. Participate in Banned Books Week: Join events and discussions celebrating the freedom to read.
  2. Donate to Libraries and Advocacy Groups: Organizations like the ALA and PEN America work tirelessly to protect intellectual freedom.
  3. Wear Your Support: Celebrate your love for banned books with bookish apparel. Check out Bookish Wardrobe for cozy hoodies and tees that champion the freedom to read.
  4. Start a Banned Books Club: Gather friends to read and discuss banned books, creating a space for open dialogue and exploration.

Final Thoughts

The banning of books may seem like a relic of the past, but it remains a pressing issue in today’s America. These challenges serve as a reminder of the power of literature to provoke thought, inspire change, and question the status quo. By reading banned books, we not only celebrate the stories that shape our world but also champion the fundamental right to think, question, and explore freely.

So, grab a banned book, curl up in your favorite bookish sweatshirt, and celebrate the transformative power of stories. Happy reading! 📚✨

Back to blog

Check out our collections