
How to Host a Bookish Gift Exchange (Not Just for Holidays!)
Table of content
- 1. Key Takeaways
- 2. Why Host a Bookish Gift Exchange Year-Round?
- 3. Choosing the Right Format: Secret Swap, Open Exchange, or Pair-Up
- 4. Picking a Fun and Easy Theme
- 5. Setting Expectations: Budget, Shipping, and Deadlines
- 6. What to Include: Books and Beyond
- 7. Making It Personal: Notes, Annotations, and Recommendations
- 8. Hosting a Reveal: Virtual or In-Person Ideas
- 9. Extra Tips from Book Lovers Who’ve Done It
Key Takeaways
- A bookish gift exchange can happen any time of year, not just at Christmas.
- Use clear themes (like genres or book covers) to make the swap fun.
- Set price limits and deadlines to keep the exchange fair for everyone.
- Add personal notes or bookish extras to make each gift feel special.
- You can do this in-person or online — even with people from other countries.
Why Host a Bookish Gift Exchange Year-Round?
Most people think of gift exchanges as a holiday-only event. But for book lovers, swapping books can be a fun way to stay connected throughout the year — no holiday required.
Here’s why it works well all year:
- It brings people together in a low-pressure, book-focused way.
- It gives everyone a chance to discover new titles or authors.
- It keeps your book club or online reading group active between meetings.
If you need inspiration on why books make the best gifts in any season, check out this guide on practical bookish gift ideas.
Choosing the Right Format: Secret Swap, Open Exchange, or Pair-Up
The way you structure your bookish gift exchange matters. Here are three easy formats:
Format | How It Works | Best For |
Secret Swap | Random draw, names kept secret until reveal | Larger groups |
Open Exchange | Everyone brings a book and swaps randomly | Parties or casual clubs |
Pair-Up | People are matched and exchange directly | Small, close groups |
For digital organizing, try tools like Elfster or even a simple Google Sheet.
Picking a Fun and Easy Theme
Themes add personality to your swap. They help guide what to give and make the results more interesting.
Ideas include:
- Genre-based (sci-fi, memoirs, fantasy)
- Mood-based (comfort reads, thrillers, feel-good stories)
- Visual themes (books with blue covers, minimalist artwork)
You can also organize by bookshelf styles. If you're curious about that, here's a look at why color-coded bookshelves are trendy.
Setting Expectations: Budget, Shipping, and Deadlines
To keep the swap fair and smooth:
- Set a price range (like $10–$20 total, including extras).
- Decide if used books are okay or if gifts should be new.
- Make deadlines clear — especially if shipping is involved.
If you’re mailing internationally, check timelines like those listed on the USPS holiday schedule.
What to Include: Books and Beyond
You don’t have to send only books. Many readers love small add-ons.
Some fun extras:
- Bookmarks or sticky tabs
- Candles, tea, or snacks
- Literary-themed apparel or accessories
For a full guide, check out how to build a personalized book gift box.
Making It Personal: Notes, Annotations, and Recommendations
The best gifts feel personal — even if the sender is anonymous. That’s why handwritten notes go a long way.You could include:
- A note about why you picked the book
- A quote you loved
- A “read this if you liked…” list
Want to include trivia with your note? Try something from this fun list of bookish facts.
Hosting a Reveal: Virtual or In-Person Ideas
Plan a reveal event — it’s the most exciting part! If you’re meeting in person, bring snacks and wear your favorite book-themed shirt. If you’re online, use a platform like Zoom or Discord.
Fun ideas:
- Everyone guesses who their gifter was.
- Host a mini book trivia game.
- Share your reactions live!
To make it extra engaging, check out these interactive book club activities.
Extra Tips from Book Lovers Who’ve Done It
Here are some helpful tips from readers who’ve hosted gift exchanges before:
- Have a backup gift ready, just in case someone forgets.
- Use an anonymous survey to gather favorite genres or authors.
- Add a “wild card” gift — something random and fun.
Need more gift inspiration? Browse these book-themed gift ideas.
Can we host a bookish gift exchange more than once a year?
Yes! Try it every season or at the end of each book club cycle.
What if someone doesn’t like their gift?
It happens. Remind participants to keep an open mind — it could lead to discovering a new favorite.
Can we include digital books or audiobooks?
Absolutely. Send Kindle or Audible codes, or links from Bookshop.org.
How do we include teens or kids in the swap?
Use age categories and include middle grade or young adult books for younger readers.
Should gifts be wrapped?
Yes, even simply! Wrapping adds a layer of fun and mystery.